Acupuncture Interlude

I don’t know, maybe someone will find something philosophical to say about this:

(from a yahoo news link)


WEDNESDAY, Jan. 28 (HealthDay News) — When used to treat pain, acupuncture offers only limited relief that may not be clinically relevant.

So say Danish researchers who examined data from 13 acupuncture pain studies that included more than 3,000 patients.

The studies compared real acupuncture, placebo acupuncture and no acupuncture for a wide range of painful conditions such as knee osteoarthritis, migraine, low back pain and postoperative pain.

Compared to placebo acupuncture, real acupuncture offered only a small amount of relief (about 4 millimeters on a 100-mm pain scoring scale), according to the review authors. A 10-mm change on this scale is classified as “minimal” or “little change,” which means the apparent relief offered by acupuncture seems to be below clinically relevant improvement.

The findings, published online Jan. 28 in the British Medical Journal, support a number of previous reviews that found no clear evidence that acupuncture offers effective pain relief.

Future studies should focus on reducing bias and trying to separate the physiological effect of using a needle and the psychological impact of the treatment ritual, said the researchers at the Nordic Cochrane Center in Copenhagen.

The overall effect of acupuncture in relation to usual care may not be large, but it may be clinically relevant for musculoskeletal conditions due to the limited treatment options and acupuncture’s safety record and patient preference, Dr. Adrian White and Dr. Mike Cummings of the British Medical Acupuncture Society wrote in an accompanying editorial.

Future research should focus on a comparison of acupuncture with the best existing treatments for different conditions, they suggested.

More information

The U.S. National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine has more about acupuncture.


It’s true, I’m too busy at the moment to generate my own material…

One thought on “Acupuncture Interlude

  1. Hi Manyul,

    Nothing philosophical– just personal experience but I have seen an acupuncturist here in Japan (Beijing-trained) for about 10 years. The reduction in pain is not minimal but substantial– as far as this being placebo or not, well, the treatment itself is extraordinarily relaxing and so as a person relaxes (a similar effect to having a glass of wine), I relax, blood seems to actually start flowing, I may actually start breathing again and then often I fall asleep. So with that in mind, plus if you don’t really buy into all this mind-body duality stuff…. I don’t know– for migraine and backpain or there are a few other things as well that the treatment is probably pretty appropriate for. A friend who gave birth in Stockholm said it was available in hospitals labor pain.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.