Author Archives: Steve Angle

Vassar Symposium: Introductions to Classical Chinese Philosophy

At Bryan Van Norden’s institgation, a few of us are going to gather at Vassar on June 8-9 to present introductory lectures on key figures in classical Chinese philosophy, and then discuss our approaches. This will be an ideal opportunity for colleagues who are not specialists in early Chinese thought (be they philosophers, sinologists, interested students, etc.) to get a concentrated introduction to these great thinkers and texts. In addition, we welcome any specialists who would like to join in the discussions, both formal and informal. There will also be a session near the end in which all are invited to discuss some recent secondary scholarship. Please see below for details.

Continue reading →

Wikipedia and Modern Chinese Philosophy

Like many of you, I suspect, I regularly use Wikipedia as a first-stop when looking something up on the internet. It has many limitations, of course, but often enough it proves useful. It is only as useful as its contributors make it, though. Since I have been struck by the paucity of informaton in Wikipedia concerning topics in 20th-century Chinese philosophy, I decided to see what would happen if I made improving a Wikipedia page one of the assignments in my Modern Chinese Philosophy course this semester.  Continue reading →

Reviews of Chinese Edition of Human Rights and Chinese Thought

I apologize if I am the only one who finds this fascinating! But I just learned that the Chinese edition of Human Rights and Chinese Thought, published a couple months ago by Renmin University Press as 《人权与中国思想:一种跨文化的探索》, is the subject of some reviews and excerpts on the “Reading Weekly 读药周刊” website.   Continue reading →

SACP Submission Deadline Extended for 2012 Eastern APA

DEADLINE EXTENDED

2012 Eastern Division Conference of the American Philosophical Association

December 27-30, Atlanta, GA

Please submit individual paper abstracts or complete panel proposals for this year’s SACP Panels at the American Philosophical Association Eastern Division Meeting in Atlanta, GA. Paper abstracts should be 150-200 words in length, and complete panel abstracts should include a 150 word introduction to the theme of the panel, complete with panel title, along with 150 word abstracts for each of the papers.  Please include each presenter’s name, e-mail address, and institution.  Please submit these materials no later than May 21, 2012 to Brian Bruya at bbruya@emich.edu.

Do China’s Traditions Make Chinese People Illogical?

Apparently there is a current meme in China alledging that Chinese people are too often illogical (and, instead, swayed by rhetoric, emotions, and politics) and that the cause of this may be the lack of concern for logical reasoning in China’s philsoophical traditions. Recently a journalist from the magazine Window on the Southern Wind 南风窗 interviewed well-known CASS philosopher Zhao Tingyang concerning these ideas.  The conversation is pretty interesting: Zhao suggests that too much attention to “dialectic” and too little training in logic–and, more generally, in critical reasoning–is the main culprit. He grants that early Chinese classics mainly were concerned with “thought 思想” rather than “theory 理论,” and adds that in this context:

…有些观念之间不一致也不足为奇,而且还必须考虑到,生活本身充满矛盾,因此,表达生活的思想有些互相矛盾,反而是如实反映了生活。这不是不讲逻辑。

…to have some inconsistencies between a few concepts would not be odd; and we should also consider, life itself is full of contraditions, therefore “thought” that seeks to express life and thus has some self-contradictions is actually in this way reflecting life. This is not to be illogical.

In light of all this, Joachim Kurz’s recent Discovery of Chinese Logic takes on added significance. (My review of Kurz’s excellent book can be found here.)

New Scholarship on 20th Century Chinese Philosophy

As the semester winds toward its end, and with it, my class on Modern Chinese Philosophy,I find myself reflecting on how much new scholarship has become available on 20th- and 21st-century Chinese philosophy in just the last 18 months. Most of these books are, alas, quite expensive, but the quality is very high. This slew of excellent books makes me feel that the field of modern Chinese philosophy has suddenly come of age — and, at the same time, become eminently teachable. Reflect with me on this list:

Continue reading →

Neo-Confucianism Seminar Next Friday

The next session of the Columbia University Seminar on Neo-Confucian Studies will convene on Friday, May 4, from 3:30 to 5:30pm in the Heyman Center for the Humanities at Columbia University.

We will have two presenters (listed here in alphabetical order):

  • Agnes Chalier will present the paper “Many Voices of Earlier Chinese Texts and their Relationship to China, Today.”
  • Wen-Sheng Wang of National Chengchi University, Taiwan will present the paper “How Can we Express What is Implied in Our Life?   A Comparative Examination of Husserl, Heidegger, Arendt, and Tang Chun-I.”

Continue reading →